American Idol Inconsistency
The judges on American Idol seem to be horribly inconsistent. We were watching the auditions from last Tuesday tonight, and they were picking on this girl who was like the best singer of the year. They told her she wasn’t super star enough and made her come back. I don’t mind that they did this inherently, but they needed to say something like, “Okay, you are one of the best we’ve heard, but we think you can be special so…”
I will do this in class sometimes if I am reading a good rough draft. I will say, “Okay this is good, but now I am going to be picky so we can make this great.” I just worry that the girl left the audition thinking she was bad.
Popularity: unranked [?]
Tags: American Idol
